Erin Theiller scored the winner off a pass from Abbie Urbanak in the second overtime as host John Jay edged Horace Greeley, 2-1, in girls soccer on Wednesday.
Kylie Longin dished the ball to Urbanak, who then sent a long cross to Theiller on the right. With the goalie drawn toward her, Theiller headed the ball toward the left corner with three minutes left in the extra period.
“It wasn’t a designed play,” Patriots coach C.J. Greenwood said. “Erin is known for running up the middle of the field when we get the ball and Abby spotted her, and away it went.”
Brianna Durland made 11 saves for John Jay (10-3-1).
Melissa McHugh scored off a feed from Claire Thoma in the 18th minute to give the Patriots a 1-0 lead, but Horace Greeley tied it 14 minutes into the second half.
“We were happy to get the win and put another one under the belt,” Greenwood said. “Now we turn our attention to Ketcham.”
John Jay hosts Roy C. Ketcham at 6:30 p.m. Friday at McGrath Field.
Arlington 5, Carmel 0 — Rachael Moran scored three goals in the first half and Molly Feighan had three assists to lead visiting Arlington. Haleigh Schanz added a goal and an assist, Meggie Buttinger scored a goal, and Allie Coon had an assist. Lauren Neville made three saves for the Admirals (10-4).
Arlington hosts Mahopac at 4:15 p.m. Friday.
Beacon 6, Hendrick Hudson 1 — Chloe Antalek and Reanna Cader each scored twice and Eliza Ericson had a goal and an assist to lead host Beacon. Yulissa Lotero also scored and Leah Giavatto had an assist for the Bulldogs (4-9-1). Beacon visits Walter Panas at 4:15 p.m. Friday.
Arlington B 1, Haldane 1 — Claire Kirkhus scored for host Arlington B, but Haldane’s Hannah Monteleone answered 10 minutes later. The game was called for darkness before overtime. Arlington B is 9-2-2.
Saugerties 2, Highland 0 — Alexis Rivera made 13 saves in the loss for Highland (3-8-2). Saugerties had 15 shots on goal and Madison Conlin’s goal put them on the board late in the first half.
Millbrook 0, Onteora 0 — Claire Martell made 12 saves in the tie for host Millbrook.
Marlboro 3, Franklin D. Roosevelt 1 — Hannah Sullivan scored once and added two assists to lead the host Iron Dukes. Taylor DuBois and Taylor Guido also scored, while Joyce Rider made an assist.
Eliz Fino and Emily Mott each made two saves for Marlboro (5-6).
Sydney Currier scored on an assist by Ryan-Marie Duncan for the Presidents’ lone goal. Kelsie McDowell had five saves for Roosevelt (3-7-1).
Putnam Valley 3, Pawling 0 — Kelly Koerner made 13 saves in the loss for host Pawling (0-12). The Tigers visit Haldane at 5 p.m. Thursday.
Walter Panas 2, Our Lady of Lourdes 1 – Kelly Keenan scored unassisted in the 24th minute for Lourdes (2-11). Kayla Moschetti made four saves for the Warriors.
Panas tied it in the 45th minute and scored the winner in the 70th minute.
Lourdes visits Lakeland at 4:30 p.m. Friday.